Ranking the 25 Best Return Specialists in NFL History
The return specialist position, encompassing both kick returners and punt returners, has been one of the most electrifying and game-changing roles in NFL special teams since the league's inception, with players tasked with flipping field position, providing a spark for their teams, and executing game-breaking plays. Throughout the history of professional football, the return specialist position has produced some of the most thrilling, impactful, and unforgettable players to ever step onto the gridiron, leaving indelible marks on the sport.
From lightning-fast kick returners with unparalleled elusiveness to sure-handed punt returners who can make the first defender miss, this list represents the very best of what the position has to offer. These elite return specialists have redefined the position, set new standards for excellence, and inspired generations of return specialists who have followed in their footsteps.
Without further ado, here is our ranking of the 25 best return specialists in NFL history:
(If you didn’t catch Ranking the 25 Best Punters in NFL History, you can read that here.)
25. Desmond Howard
Team(s):
- Washington Redskins (1992-1994)
- Jacksonville Jaguars (1995)
- Green Bay Packers (1996, 1999)
- Oakland Raiders (1997-1998)
- Detroit Lions (1999-2002)
Accolades:
- Hall of Fame induction: No
- First-Team All-Pro selections: 1
- Pro Bowls: 1
Summary:
Desmond Howard, a dynamic and clutch return specialist, left a lasting impact on the NFL during his 11-year career, most notably with the Green Bay Packers. Known for his explosive speed, elusiveness, and ability to deliver in big moments, Howard established himself as one of the most memorable and impactful return specialists of his era.
Howard began his NFL career with the Washington Redskins in 1992 as a first-round draft pick. Despite initial struggles to find his footing as a wide receiver, Howard quickly made his mark on special teams. His exceptional speed, vision, and agility made him a constant threat to break off long returns and change the momentum of games.
Howard's peak single-season performance came in 1996, his first year with the Green Bay Packers. He amassed an impressive 875 punt return yards and scored three punt return touchdowns, showcasing his ability to make defenders miss and create big plays. Additionally, he contributed 460 kick return yards, further demonstrating his impact on the return game. Howard's all-purpose yardage that season totaled 1,430 yards, highlighting his versatility and value to the team.
Throughout his career, Howard consistently demonstrated his game-changing ability on both punt and kick returns. He accumulated 2,895 punt return yards and scored eight punt return touchdowns, using his speed and elusiveness to create big plays. As a kick returner, Howard was equally impressive, amassing 7,959 kick return yards and scoring five kick return touchdowns.
Howard's most memorable moment came during Super Bowl XXXI, where he delivered a historic performance. He returned a kickoff 99 yards for a touchdown, electrifying the crowd and sealing the Packers' victory over the New England Patriots. Howard's Super Bowl MVP award was a testament to his impact on the game and his ability to rise to the occasion on the biggest stage.
In addition to his return skills, Howard also contributed as a wide receiver, catching 123 passes for 1,597 yards and seven touchdowns throughout his career. While his offensive numbers may not have been as gaudy as his return stats, Howard's versatility and willingness to contribute in multiple facets of the game made him a valuable asset to his teams.
Howard's exceptional performance in 1996 earned him individual accolades, as he was selected to the Pro Bowl and named First-Team All-Pro. His clutch performances and game-changing ability on special teams made him a respected and feared opponent.
Off the field, Howard was known for his strong work ethic, leadership, and dedication to his craft. He was a respected teammate and a positive influence in the locker room.
Desmond Howard's legacy as one of the greatest return specialists in NFL history is firmly established. His explosive speed, elusiveness, and ability to deliver in big moments made him a constant threat and a game-changer on special teams. Howard's contributions to the Packers' Super Bowl victory and his impact on the return game throughout his career will always be remembered and celebrated by fans and football enthusiasts. His career serves as a testament to the value of explosive playmaking ability, versatility, and the potential to rise to the occasion when it matters most.
24. Darren Sproles
Team(s):
- San Diego Chargers (2005-2010)
- New Orleans Saints (2011-2013)
- Philadelphia Eagles (2014-2019)
Accolades:
- Hall of Fame induction: No
- First-Team All-Pro selections: 1
- Pro Bowls: 3
Summary:
Darren Sproles, a versatile and electrifying return specialist, carved out an impressive 15-year career in the NFL, showcasing his skills with the San Diego Chargers, New Orleans Saints, and Philadelphia Eagles. Known for his exceptional quickness, elusiveness, and game-breaking ability, Sproles established himself as one of the most dynamic and impactful return specialists in league history.
Sproles began his NFL career with the San Diego Chargers in 2005, where he quickly made a name for himself as a dual-threat running back and return specialist. His ability to make defenders miss in the open field and his explosive speed made him a constant threat on special teams.
Sproles' peak single-season performance came in 2007, his second year in the league. He amassed an impressive 229 punt return yards and scored one punt return touchdown, while also contributing 1,008 kick return yards and scoring one kick return touchdown. His all-purpose yardage totaled 1,432, showcasing his impact on the game as a returner and offensive weapon.
Throughout his career, Sproles proved to be a consistent and reliable return specialist. He accumulated 2,961 punt return yards and scored seven punt return touchdowns, demonstrating his ability to change the game with his return skills. Additionally, he totaled 8,352 kick return yards and scored two kick return touchdowns.
Sproles' versatility and impact on the game extended beyond his return abilities. He was also a key contributor on offense, amassing 19,696 all-purpose yards throughout his career. His elusiveness and receiving skills made him a valuable asset in the passing game, while his vision and agility allowed him to be effective as a runner.
After his time with the Chargers, Sproles spent three seasons with the New Orleans Saints before joining the Philadelphia Eagles in 2014. With the Eagles, Sproles continued to excel as a return specialist and offensive weapon, earning three consecutive Pro Bowl selections from 2014 to 2016.
Sproles' contributions to the game were recognized by his peers and the league, as he was named to the Pro Bowl three times and earned First-Team All-Pro honors in 2014. His impact on the Eagles' special teams unit and offense was undeniable, as he consistently provided a spark and game-changing plays.
Off the field, Sproles was respected for his work ethic, leadership, and positive influence on his teammates. Despite his smaller stature, he played with a fearless and competitive spirit that endeared him to fans and fellow players alike.
Darren Sproles' legacy as one of the most dynamic and versatile return specialists in NFL history is secure. His ability to impact the game as a returner, runner, and receiver set him apart from his peers. Sproles' contributions to the Chargers, Saints, and Eagles franchises, as well as his impact on the return game as a whole, will always be remembered and celebrated by fans and football enthusiasts. His career serves as a testament to the value of versatility, determination, and the ability to make game-changing plays in all phases of the game.
23. Brian Mitchell
Team(s):
- Washington Redskins (1990-1999)
- Philadelphia Eagles (2000-2002)
- New York Giants (2003)
Accolades:
- Hall of Fame induction: No
- First-Team All-Pro selections: 1
- Pro Bowls: 1
Summary:
Brian Mitchell, a durable and consistently productive return specialist, enjoyed a remarkable 14-year career in the NFL, primarily with the Washington Redskins. Known for his versatility, reliable hands, and ability to break long returns, Mitchell established himself as one of the most prolific return specialists in league history.
Mitchell began his NFL career with the Washington Redskins in 1990, where he quickly became a key contributor on special teams. His vision, agility, and toughness made him a constant threat as both a punt and kick returner.
Mitchell's peak single-season performance came in 1994 when he truly showcased his game-changing abilities. He amassed 452 punt return yards and scored two punt return touchdowns, while also contributing 1,478 kick return yards. His all-purpose yardage totaled an impressive 2,477, highlighting his impact on the game as a returner and offensive weapon.
Throughout his career, Mitchell's consistency and durability were remarkable. He ranks second all-time in both career punt return yards (4,999) and career kick return yards (14,014). His nine punt return touchdowns and four kick return touchdowns further demonstrate his ability to change the game with his return skills.
In addition to his return abilities, Mitchell was also a valuable contributor on offense. He ranks second all-time in career all-purpose yards with 23,330, showcasing his versatility as a runner, receiver, and returner.
After his tenure with the Redskins, Mitchell spent three seasons with the Philadelphia Eagles before playing his final season with the New York Giants in 2003. Throughout his career, he remained a reliable and impactful player on special teams.
Mitchell's contributions to the game were recognized by his peers and the league, as he was selected to the Pro Bowl and named First-Team All-Pro in 1995. His longevity and consistent production made him a respected figure in the NFL.
Off the field, Mitchell was known for his professionalism, work ethic, and leadership. He was a positive influence on his teammates and a role model for younger players.
Brian Mitchell's legacy as one of the most prolific and versatile return specialists in NFL history is undeniable. His durability, consistency, and ability to impact the game in multiple phases set him apart from his peers. Mitchell's contributions to the Redskins, Eagles, and Giants franchises, as well as his impact on the return game as a whole, will always be remembered and celebrated by fans and football enthusiasts. His career serves as a testament to the value of versatility, reliability, and the ability to consistently produce at a high level over a long period of time.
22. Terrence McGee
Team(s):
- Buffalo Bills (2003-2012)
Accolades:
- Hall of Fame induction: No
- First-Team All-Pro selections: 0
- Pro Bowls: 1
Summary:
Terrence McGee, a speedy and elusive return specialist, spent his entire 10-year NFL career with the Buffalo Bills. Known for his explosive playmaking ability and knack for finding the end zone, McGee established himself as one of the most dangerous return threats in the league during his prime.
McGee joined the Bills in 2003 as a fourth-round draft pick and immediately made an impact on special teams. His speed, agility, and vision made him a constant threat as both a punt and kick returner.
McGee's peak single-season performance came in 2004 when he truly showcased his game-breaking abilities. He returned an impressive 1,370 kick return yards and scored three kick return touchdowns. His electrifying returns and ability to flip field position quickly made him a valuable asset to the Bills' special teams unit.
Throughout his career, McGee consistently demonstrated his ability to make big plays in the return game. He recorded a total of 1,370 kick return yards and five kick return touchdowns, highlighting his speed and breakaway ability.
In addition to his return skills, McGee was also a solid contributor on defense as a cornerback. His versatility and athleticism allowed him to make an impact on both special teams and defense.
McGee's contributions to the Bills' special teams unit were recognized in 2004 when he was selected to the Pro Bowl. His explosive playmaking ability and consistency in the return game made him a respected figure among his peers.
Off the field, McGee was known for his professionalism and dedication to his craft. He was a team player and a positive influence in the locker room.
Terrence McGee's legacy as one of the most electric return specialists in NFL history is secure. His ability to change the game with his return skills and his consistency throughout his career set him apart from many of his contemporaries. McGee's impact on the Bills' franchise and the return game as a whole will always be remembered by fans and football enthusiasts. His career serves as a testament to the value of explosive playmaking ability, versatility, and the potential to swing momentum with game-changing returns.
21. Mel Gray
Team(s):
- New Orleans Saints (1986-1988)
- Detroit Lions (1989-1994)
- Houston Oilers (1995-1996)
- Tennessee Oilers (1997)
- Philadelphia Eagles (1997)
Accolades:
- Hall of Fame induction: No
- First-Team All-Pro selections: 3
- Pro Bowls: 4
Summary:
Mel Gray, a dynamic and consistently productive return specialist, enjoyed a successful 12-year career in the NFL, showcasing his skills with the New Orleans Saints, Detroit Lions, Houston Oilers, and Tennessee Oilers. Known for his blazing speed, elusiveness, and game-breaking ability, Gray established himself as one of the most feared return specialists of his era.
Gray began his NFL career with the New Orleans Saints in 1986, where he quickly made a name for himself as a dangerous return threat. His exceptional speed and vision made him a constant source of excitement on special teams.
Gray's peak single-season performance came in 1994 with the Detroit Lions. He amassed an impressive 233 punt return yards, while also contributing 1,276 kick return yards and three kick return touchdowns. His ability to consistently provide good field position and create game-changing plays made him an invaluable asset to his team.
Throughout his career, Gray's production and impact on the return game were remarkable. He ranks ninth all-time in career punt return yards with 3,151 and scored six punt return touchdowns, showcasing his elusiveness and ability to break long returns. Additionally, he accumulated 6,758 kick return yards and scored three kick return touchdowns.
Gray's performances earned him recognition as one of the best return specialists of his time. He was selected to four Pro Bowls (1987, 1991, 1992, 1994) and named First-Team All-Pro four times (1987, 1991, 1992, 1994), cementing his status as an elite player at his position.
After his time with the Lions, Gray spent two seasons with the Houston Oilers before playing his final season with the Tennessee Oilers in 1997. Throughout his career, he remained a consistent threat on special teams and a respected figure in the NFL.
Off the field, Gray was known for his strong work ethic and dedication to his craft. He was a team player and a positive presence in the locker room.
Mel Gray's legacy as one of the most dynamic and consistently productive return specialists in NFL history is firmly established. His speed, elusiveness, and ability to change the game with his return skills set him apart from his peers. Gray's contributions to the Saints, Lions, and Oilers franchises, as well as his impact on the return game as a whole, will always be remembered and celebrated by fans and football enthusiasts. His career serves as a testament to the value of game-breaking ability, consistency, and the potential to swing momentum with electrifying returns.
20. Jamal Agnew
Team(s):
- Detroit Lions (2017-2020)
- Jacksonville Jaguars (2021-2023)
Accolades:
- Hall of Fame induction: No
- First-Team All-Pro selections: 1
- Pro Bowls: 1
Summary:
Jamal Agnew, a dynamic and explosive return specialist, has made a significant impact in the NFL since entering the league in 2017. Known for his game-breaking speed, elusiveness, and ability to create big plays, Agnew has established himself as one of the most exciting return specialists of his generation.
Agnew began his NFL career with the Detroit Lions in 2017, where he immediately made an impact as a punt and kick returner. His exceptional speed and vision quickly made him a fan favorite and a constant threat on special teams.
Agnew's peak single-season performance came in his rookie year, 2017. He amassed 447 punt return yards and scored two punt return touchdowns, showcasing his ability to make game-changing plays. His electrifying returns and potential to flip field position quickly earned him recognition as a First-Team All-Pro and a Pro Bowl selection in his debut season.
Throughout his career, Agnew has continued to showcase his talents as a return specialist. He has accumulated 1,280 punt return yards and scored four punt return touchdowns, demonstrating his elusiveness and ability to make defenders miss in the open field. Additionally, he has contributed 3,112 kick return yards and two kick return touchdowns.
In addition to his return skills, Agnew has also showcased his versatility by contributing on offense as a wide receiver and on defense as a cornerback. His athleticism and playmaking ability have made him a valuable asset to his teams.
After spending four seasons with the Detroit Lions, Agnew joined the Jacksonville Jaguars in 2021, where he has continued to make an impact on special teams.
Off the field, Agnew is known for his positive attitude, work ethic, and leadership skills. He is a respected figure in the locker room and a role model for younger players.
Jamal Agnew's legacy as one of the most electric return specialists in NFL history is secure. His speed, elusiveness, and ability to create big plays have made him a constant threat on special teams. Agnew's impact on the Lions and Jaguars franchises, as well as his potential to alter the course of a game with his return skills, have earned him recognition as one of the best return specialists of his era. His career serves as a testament to the value of explosive playmaking ability, versatility, and the potential to swing momentum with electrifying returns. As Agnew continues his NFL journey, he has the opportunity to further cement his place among the all-time great return specialists in league history.
19. Jakeem Grant
Team(s):
- Miami Dolphins (2016-2021)
- Chicago Bears (2021)
- Cleveland Browns (2022-2023)
Accolades:
- Hall of Fame induction: No
- First-Team All-Pro selections: 1
- Pro Bowls: 1
Summary:
Jakeem Grant, a speedy and elusive return specialist, has made a significant impact in the NFL since entering the league in 2016. Known for his explosive playmaking ability, agility, and game-breaking speed, Grant has established himself as one of the most dangerous return threats in the league.
Grant began his NFL career with the Miami Dolphins in 2016, where he quickly made a name for himself as a dynamic return specialist. Despite his smaller stature, Grant's exceptional quickness and vision made him a constant source of excitement on special teams.
Grant's peak single-season performance came in 2018 when he truly showcased his game-changing abilities. He amassed 228 punt return yards and scored one punt return touchdown, while also contributing 535 kick return yards and one kick return touchdown. His electric returns and ability to create big plays earned him recognition as one of the best return specialists in the league.
Throughout his career, Grant has consistently demonstrated his ability to make an impact in the return game. He has accumulated 1,228 punt return yards and scored four punt return touchdowns, showcasing his elusiveness and ability to make defenders miss in the open field. Additionally, he has contributed 2,699 kick return yards and two kick return touchdowns.
In addition to his return skills, Grant has also showcased his versatility as a wide receiver. His speed and agility make him a dangerous threat in the passing game, capable of stretching the field and creating mismatches against opposing defenses.
After spending five seasons with the Miami Dolphins, Grant was traded to the Chicago Bears during the 2021 season. He continued to make an impact on special teams and was selected to the Pro Bowl for the 2021 season. In 2023, Grant joined the Cleveland Browns, where he has the opportunity to further showcase his return skills and contribute to the team's success.
Off the field, Grant is known for his positive attitude, strong work ethic, and infectious energy. He is a respected figure in the locker room and a fan favorite due to his exciting playmaking ability.
Jakeem Grant's legacy as one of the most dynamic and versatile return specialists in NFL history is secure. His speed, elusiveness, and ability to create big plays have made him a constant threat on special teams. Grant's impact on the Dolphins, Bears, and Browns franchises, as well as his potential to alter the course of a game with his return skills, have earned him recognition as one of the best return specialists of his era. His career serves as a testament to the value of explosive playmaking ability, versatility, and the potential to swing momentum with electrifying returns. As Grant continues his NFL journey, he has the opportunity to further cement his place among the all-time great return specialists in league history.
18. Abe Woodson
Team(s):
- San Francisco 49ers (1958-1964)
- St. Louis Cardinals (1965-1966)
Accolades:
- Hall of Fame induction: No
- First-Team All-Pro selections: 2
- Pro Bowls: 5
Summary:
Abe Woodson, a trailblazing return specialist and defensive back, made a significant impact in the NFL during his nine-year career, primarily with the San Francisco 49ers. Known for his incredible speed, elusiveness, and game-changing ability, Woodson established himself as one of the premier return specialists of his era.
Woodson joined the San Francisco 49ers in 1958 and quickly made his mark as a dynamic returner. His exceptional speed and vision made him a constant threat on both punt and kick returns, often leaving defenders grasping at air as he raced towards the end zone.
Woodson's peak single-season performance came in 1963 when he truly showcased his game-breaking abilities. He amassed 95 punt return yards, while also contributing an impressive 935 kick return yards and three kick return touchdowns. His electrifying returns and ability to change the momentum of a game earned him recognition as a First-Team All-Pro and Pro Bowl selection for the 1963 season.
Throughout his career, Woodson consistently demonstrated his prowess as a return specialist. He accumulated 956 punt return yards and scored two punt return touchdowns, showcasing his elusiveness and ability to make defenders miss in the open field. Additionally, he contributed 5,538 kick return yards and five kick return touchdowns, highlighting his speed and breakaway ability.
In addition to his return skills, Woodson was also a standout defensive back. His speed and athleticism made him a formidable force in the secondary, where he excelled in coverage and had a knack for making game-changing plays.
Woodson's contributions to the 49ers and the NFL were recognized with two First-Team All-Pro selections (1959, 1960) and five Pro Bowl appearances (1959, 1960, 1961, 1962, 1963), cementing his status as one of the best return specialists and defensive backs of his time.
After seven seasons with the 49ers, Woodson played his final two seasons with the St. Louis Cardinals before retiring from the NFL in 1966.
Off the field, Woodson was known for his dedication to the game and his community. He served as a role model for young players and was respected by his teammates and opponents alike.
Abe Woodson's legacy as one of the greatest return specialists in NFL history is secure. His incredible speed, elusiveness, and game-changing ability made him a constant threat on special teams and a respected figure in the NFL. Woodson's impact on the 49ers franchise and the return game as a whole will always be remembered and celebrated by fans and football historians. His career serves as a testament to the value of explosive playmaking ability, versatility, and the potential to alter the course of a game with electrifying returns.
17. Leon Washington
Team(s):
- New York Jets (2006-2009)
- Seattle Seahawks (2010-2012)
- New England Patriots (2013)
- Tennessee Titans (2014)
Accolades:
- Hall of Fame induction: No
- First-Team All-Pro selections: 1
- Pro Bowls: 2
Summary:
Leon Washington, a dynamic and versatile return specialist, made a significant impact in the NFL during his nine-year career, showcasing his skills with the New York Jets, Seattle Seahawks, New England Patriots, and Tennessee Titans. Known for his explosive speed, elusiveness, and game-breaking ability, Washington established himself as one of the most feared return specialists of his era.
Washington began his NFL career with the New York Jets in 2006 and quickly made a name for himself as a dangerous return threat. His exceptional vision, agility, and burst made him a constant source of excitement on special teams.
Washington's peak single-season performance came in 2007, his second year with the Jets. He amassed an impressive 183 punt return yards, while also contributing 1,291 kick return yards and a remarkable three kick return touchdowns. His electric returns and ability to change field position quickly earned him recognition as a First-Team All-Pro for the 2007 season.
Throughout his career, Washington consistently demonstrated his prowess as a return specialist. He accumulated 1,793 punt return yards, showcasing his ability to make defenders miss in the open field. However, it was his kick return ability that truly set him apart. Washington amassed an impressive 7,553 kick return yards and scored eight kick return touchdowns, cementing his status as one of the most dangerous kick returners in NFL history.
In addition to his return skills, Washington was also a valuable contributor on offense as a running back. His versatility and ability to catch passes out of the backfield made him a valuable asset to his teams.
After four seasons with the Jets, Washington joined the Seattle Seahawks in 2010, where he continued to excel as a return specialist. He earned his second Pro Bowl selection in 2012 as a member of the Seahawks. Washington played one season with the New England Patriots in 2013 before concluding his career with the Tennessee Titans in 2014.
Off the field, Washington was known for his strong work ethic, leadership skills, and community involvement. He was a respected figure in the locker room and a positive influence on his teammates.
Leon Washington's legacy as one of the greatest return specialists in NFL history is firmly established. His explosive speed, elusiveness, and ability to create big plays on special teams made him a constant threat whenever he touched the ball. Washington's impact on the Jets, Seahawks, Patriots, and Titans franchises, as well as his contributions to the return game as a whole, will always be remembered and celebrated by fans and football enthusiasts. His career serves as a testament to the value of versatility, explosiveness, and the potential to swing momentum with electrifying returns.
16. Tamarick Vanover
Team(s):
- Kansas City Chiefs (1995-1999)
- San Diego Chargers (2002)
Accolades:
- Hall of Fame induction: No
- First-Team All-Pro selections: 0
- Pro Bowls: 0
Summary:
Tamarick Vanover, an electrifying return specialist, made a significant impact in the NFL during his six-year career, primarily with the Kansas City Chiefs. Known for his blistering speed, elusiveness, and game-breaking ability, Vanover quickly established himself as one of the most dangerous return threats in the league.
Vanover began his NFL career with the Kansas City Chiefs in 1995 and immediately made his presence felt on special teams. His exceptional acceleration and agility made him a constant threat to break off long returns and change the momentum of a game.
Vanover's peak single-season performance came in his rookie year, 1995. He amassed an impressive 540 punt return yards and scored one punt return touchdown, showcasing his ability to make defenders miss in the open field. Additionally, he contributed 1,095 kick return yards and scored two kick return touchdowns, solidifying his status as a dual-threat return specialist.
Throughout his career with the Chiefs, Vanover consistently demonstrated his game-changing ability on special teams. He accumulated 2,016 punt return yards and scored four punt return touchdowns, using his speed and elusiveness to create big plays. Vanover also made a significant impact as a kick returner, amassing 5,422 kick return yards and scoring four kick return touchdowns during his tenure in Kansas City.
In addition to his return skills, Vanover also contributed as a wide receiver, using his speed to stretch the field and create opportunities for the Chiefs' offense.
After five seasons with the Chiefs, Vanover spent a brief stint with the San Diego Chargers in 2002 before concluding his NFL career.
Despite not earning individual accolades such as Pro Bowl selections or All-Pro honors, Vanover's impact on the Chiefs' special teams unit and his ability to create game-changing plays cannot be overlooked. His electrifying returns and game-breaking speed made him a fan favorite and a respected opponent.
Off the field, Vanover faced some personal challenges, but he remained committed to his craft and left a lasting impact on the Chiefs organization and their fans.
Tamarick Vanover's legacy as one of the most dynamic and versatile return specialists in NFL history is secure. His blistering speed, elusiveness, and ability to create big plays on special teams made him a constant threat whenever he touched the ball. Vanover's contributions to the Chiefs franchise and the excitement he brought to the return game will always be remembered by fans and football enthusiasts. His career serves as a testament to the value of explosive playmaking ability and the potential to alter the course of a game with electrifying returns.
15. Billy Johnson
Team(s):
- Houston Oilers (1974-1980)
- Atlanta Falcons (1982-1987)
- Washington Redskins (1988)
Accolades:
- Hall of Fame induction: No
- First-Team All-Pro selections: 1
- Pro Bowls: 3
Summary:
Billy "White Shoes" Johnson, a charismatic and electrifying return specialist, left an indelible mark on the NFL during his 14-year career, primarily with the Houston Oilers and Atlanta Falcons. Known for his dynamic playmaking ability, signature white shoes, and entertaining end zone celebrations, Johnson became a fan favorite and a trailblazer for the modern return specialist.
Johnson began his NFL career with the Houston Oilers in 1974 and quickly established himself as a game-changer on special teams. His exceptional speed, elusiveness, and vision made him a constant threat to break off long returns and swing the momentum of a game.
Johnson's peak single-season performance came in 1975, his second year with the Oilers. He amassed an impressive 612 punt return yards and scored three punt return touchdowns, showcasing his ability to make defenders miss in the open field. Additionally, he contributed 798 kick return yards and scored one kick return touchdown, solidifying his status as a dual-threat return specialist.
Throughout his career, Johnson consistently demonstrated his game-breaking ability on special teams. He accumulated 3,317 punt return yards and scored six punt return touchdowns, using his speed and elusiveness to create big plays. Johnson also made a significant impact as a kick returner, amassing 2,941 kick return yards and scoring two kick return touchdowns during his time with the Oilers and Falcons.
In addition to his return skills, Johnson also contributed as a wide receiver, using his speed and route-running ability to create separation from defenders and make plays in the passing game.
Johnson's impact on the game extended beyond his on-field performance. His exuberant personality and entertaining end zone celebrations, such as the "Funky Chicken" dance, endeared him to fans and added an element of showmanship to the game. Johnson's style and flair paved the way for future generations of return specialists who would incorporate their own unique celebrations into their performances.
After seven seasons with the Oilers, Johnson joined the Atlanta Falcons in 1982, where he continued to excel as a return specialist and earned his third Pro Bowl selection in 1983. He concluded his career with a brief stint with the Washington Redskins in 1988.
Off the field, Johnson was known for his charismatic personality, infectious smile, and dedication to his craft. He was a beloved figure among teammates and fans alike, and his impact on the game extended beyond his playing days.
Billy "White Shoes" Johnson's legacy as one of the most dynamic and entertaining return specialists is firmly cemented in NFL history. His electrifying playmaking ability, signature white shoes, and pioneering end zone celebrations made him an icon of his era. Johnson's contributions to the Oilers and Falcons franchises, as well as his lasting impact on the return game and football culture, will always be remembered and celebrated by fans and football enthusiasts. His career serves as a testament to the value of showmanship, charisma, and the ability to create game-changing moments with thrilling returns.
14. Rick Upchurch
Team(s):
- Denver Broncos (1975-1983)
Accolades:
- Hall of Fame induction: No
- First-Team All-Pro selections: 3
- Pro Bowls: 4
Summary:
Rick Upchurch, a dynamic and elusive return specialist, made a lasting impact on the NFL during his nine-year career with the Denver Broncos. Known for his exceptional speed, agility, and game-breaking ability, Upchurch established himself as one of the most feared and respected return specialists of his era.
Upchurch began his NFL career with the Denver Broncos in 1975 and quickly made his presence felt on special teams. His remarkable quickness, vision, and elusiveness made him a constant threat to take any punt return the distance.
Upchurch's peak single-season performance came in 1976, his second year with the Broncos. He amassed an incredible 536 punt return yards and scored four punt return touchdowns, showcasing his ability to make defenders miss and create game-changing plays. Additionally, he contributed 514 kick return yards, further demonstrating his versatility as a return specialist.
Throughout his career, Upchurch consistently showcased his game-breaking ability on punt returns. He accumulated 3,008 punt return yards and scored eight punt return touchdowns, using his speed and elusiveness to create big plays and swing the momentum of games. Upchurch's punt return prowess earned him a reputation as one of the most dangerous returners in the league.
In addition to his punt return skills, Upchurch also made an impact as a kick returner, amassing 2,355 kick return yards during his time with the Broncos.
Upchurch's impact on the game extended beyond his return abilities. He was also a talented wide receiver, using his speed and route-running skills to create separation from defenders and make plays in the passing game. Upchurch's versatility and all-around game made him a valuable asset to the Broncos' offense and special teams.
Upchurch's consistent excellence and game-changing ability earned him numerous individual accolades. He was selected to four Pro Bowls (1976, 1978, 1979, 1982) and was named First-Team All-Pro three times (1976, 1978, 1982), cementing his status as one of the elite return specialists of his generation.
Off the field, Upchurch was known for his quiet demeanor and dedicated work ethic. He was a respected teammate and a critical component of the Broncos' success during his tenure with the team.
Rick Upchurch's legacy as one of the best return specialists in NFL history is secure. His exceptional speed, elusiveness, and ability to create big plays on punt returns made him a constant threat and a respected opponent. Upchurch's contributions to the Broncos franchise and his impact on the return game will always be remembered and celebrated by fans and football enthusiasts. His career serves as a testament to the value of explosive playmaking ability, versatility, and the potential to alter the course of a game with electrifying returns.
13. Jacoby Jones
Team(s):
- Houston Texans (2007-2011)
- Baltimore Ravens (2012-2014)
- Pittsburgh Steelers (2015)
- San Diego Chargers (2015)
Accolades:
- Hall of Fame induction: No
- First-Team All-Pro selections: 1
- Pro Bowls: 1
Summary:
Jacoby Jones, a dynamic and clutch return specialist, made a significant impact in the NFL during his nine-year career, most notably with the Houston Texans and Baltimore Ravens. Known for his game-changing ability, speed, and flair for the dramatic, Jones established himself as one of the most exciting and impactful return specialists of his era.
Jones began his NFL career with the Houston Texans in 2007 and quickly made his mark on special teams. His exceptional speed, vision, and elusiveness made him a constant threat to break off long returns and swing the momentum of games.
Jones' peak single-season performance came in 2012, his first year with the Baltimore Ravens. He amassed 341 punt return yards and scored one punt return touchdown, showcasing his ability to make defenders miss and create big plays. However, it was his kick return prowess that truly shined that season. Jones accumulated 1,167 kick return yards and scored two kick return touchdowns, including a memorable 108-yard return touchdown in Super Bowl XLVII against the San Francisco 49ers, which tied an NFL record for the longest play in Super Bowl history.
Throughout his career, Jones consistently demonstrated his game-changing ability on both punt and kick returns. He accumulated 2,688 punt return yards and scored four punt return touchdowns, using his speed and elusiveness to create big plays. As a kick returner, Jones was equally impressive, amassing 4,940 kick return yards and scoring five kick return touchdowns.
In addition to his return skills, Jones also contributed as a wide receiver, using his speed and route-running ability to create separation from defenders and make plays in the passing game. His versatility and ability to impact the game in multiple ways made him a valuable asset to his teams.
Jones' clutch performances and game-changing plays earned him individual accolades. He was selected to the Pro Bowl and named First-Team All-Pro in 2012, recognizing his exceptional performance as a return specialist.
Off the field, Jones was known for his charismatic personality and infectious energy. He was a beloved teammate and a fan favorite, thanks to his exciting play and memorable moments on the field.
Jacoby Jones' legacy as one of the most dynamic and versatile return specialists in NFL history is secure. His game-changing ability, speed, and flair for the dramatic made him a constant threat and a respected opponent. Jones' contributions to the Texans and Ravens franchises, as well as his unforgettable moments in the postseason, will always be remembered and celebrated by fans and football enthusiasts. His career serves as a testament to the value of explosive playmaking ability, versatility, and the potential to alter the course of a game with electrifying returns in the biggest moments.
12. Deion Sanders
Team(s):
- Atlanta Falcons (1989-1993)
- San Francisco 49ers (1994)
- Dallas Cowboys (1995-1999)
- Washington Redskins (2000)
- Baltimore Ravens (2004-2005)
Accolades:
- Hall of Fame induction: Yes
- First-Team All-Pro selections: 6
- Pro Bowls: 8
Summary:
Deion Sanders, a legendary cornerback and return specialist, left an indelible mark on the NFL during his 14-year career, primarily with the Atlanta Falcons, San Francisco 49ers, and Dallas Cowboys. Known for his exceptional speed, athleticism, and flamboyant personality, Sanders established himself as one of the most dynamic and influential players in NFL history.
Sanders began his NFL career with the Atlanta Falcons in 1989 and quickly demonstrated his game-changing ability on both defense and special teams. His exceptional speed, agility, and ball skills made him a shutdown cornerback, while his return abilities made him a constant threat to score whenever he touched the ball.
Sanders' peak single-season performance came in 1992, his fourth year with the Falcons. He amassed 1,067 kick return yards and scored two kick return touchdowns. On defense, Sanders intercepted six passes and returned two of them for touchdowns, further cementing his status as a game-changer on both sides of the ball.
Throughout his career, Sanders consistently demonstrated his versatility and impact on the game. As a return specialist, he accumulated 2,199 punt return yards and scored six punt return touchdowns, while also amassing 3,523 kick return yards and scoring three kick return touchdowns. His return abilities struck fear into opposing teams and consistently gave his offenses excellent field position.
As a cornerback, Sanders was equally dominant. He finished his career with 53 interceptions, returning nine of them for touchdowns. His lockdown coverage skills, combined with his speed and instincts, made him nearly impossible for wide receivers to beat.
Sanders' impact on the game extended beyond his on-field performance. His larger-than-life personality, flashy style, and entertaining celebrations made him a cultural icon and a fan favorite. Sanders' "Prime Time" persona and his ability to back up his talk with exceptional play made him one of the most recognizable and marketable stars in the NFL.
Sanders' consistent excellence and game-changing ability earned him numerous individual accolades. He was selected to eight Pro Bowls, named First-Team All-Pro six times, and inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame in 2011, cementing his status as one of the greatest players in NFL history.
Off the field, Sanders was known for his charismatic personality, business ventures, and philanthropic efforts. He remained involved in football after his playing career, working as an analyst and coach.
Deion Sanders' legacy as one of the most dynamic and influential return specialists in NFL history is secure. His exceptional speed, athleticism, and ability to impact the game on defense, special teams, and as a cultural icon made him a one-of-a-kind talent. Sanders' contributions to the Falcons, 49ers, and Cowboys franchises, as well as his lasting impact on the sport and popular culture, will always be remembered and celebrated by fans and football enthusiasts. His career serves as a testament to the value of versatility, confidence, and the ability to change the game in multiple ways.
11. Josh Cribbs
Team(s):
- Cleveland Browns (2005-2012)
- New York Jets (2013)
- Indianapolis Colts (2014)
Accolades:
- Hall of Fame induction: No
- First-Team All-Pro selections: 1
- Pro Bowls: 3
Summary:
Josh Cribbs, a versatile and dynamic return specialist, made a significant impact in the NFL during his 10-year career, most notably with the Cleveland Browns. Known for his exceptional speed, elusiveness, and game-changing ability, Cribbs established himself as one of the most feared and respected return specialists of his era.
Cribbs began his NFL career with the Cleveland Browns in 2005 as an undrafted free agent and quickly made his mark on special teams. His remarkable athleticism, vision, and toughness made him a constant threat to break off long returns and swing the momentum of games.
Cribbs' peak single-season performance came in 2009, his fifth year with the Browns. He amassed 452 punt return yards and scored one punt return touchdown, showcasing his ability to make defenders miss and create big plays. However, it was his kick return prowess that truly shined that season. Cribbs accumulated 1,542 kick return yards and scored three kick return touchdowns, cementing his status as one of the most dangerous kick returners in the league.
Throughout his career, Cribbs consistently demonstrated his game-breaking ability on both punt and kick returns. He accumulated 2,375 punt return yards and scored three punt return touchdowns, using his speed and elusiveness to create big plays. As a kick returner, Cribbs was equally impressive, amassing a staggering 11,113 kick return yards and scoring eight kick return touchdowns. His kick return yardage ranks third all-time in NFL history, a testament to his longevity and impact on the game.
In addition to his return skills, Cribbs also contributed as a wide receiver and wildcat quarterback, using his versatility and athleticism to create mismatches and add another dimension to his team's offense. His all-purpose yardage totaled 15,453 yards, further highlighting his impact on the game.
Cribbs' consistent excellence and game-changing ability earned him numerous individual accolades. He was selected to three Pro Bowls (2007, 2009, 2012) and named First-Team All-Pro one time (2009), cementing his status as one of the elite return specialists of his generation.
Off the field, Cribbs was known for his strong work ethic, leadership, and commitment to his community. He was a beloved figure in Cleveland and a respected teammate throughout his career.
Josh Cribbs' legacy as one of the most electric return specialists in NFL history is secure. His exceptional speed, elusiveness, and ability to create big plays on both punt and kick returns made him a constant threat and a respected opponent. Cribbs' contributions to the Browns franchise and his impact on the return game will always be remembered and celebrated by fans and football enthusiasts. His career serves as a testament to the value of versatility, toughness, and the potential to alter the course of a game with electrifying returns.
10. Eric Metcalf
Team(s):
- Cleveland Browns (1989-1994)
- Atlanta Falcons (1995-1996)
- San Diego Chargers (1997)
- Arizona Cardinals (1998)
- Carolina Panthers (1999)
- Washington Redskins (2000-2001)
- Green Bay Packers (2002)
Accolades:
- Hall of Fame induction: No
- First-Team All-Pro selections: 2
- Pro Bowls: 3
Summary:
Eric Metcalf, a versatile and electrifying return specialist, made a significant impact in the NFL during his 13-year career, most notably with the Cleveland Browns. Known for his exceptional speed, elusiveness, and game-breaking ability, Metcalf established himself as one of the most dynamic and feared return specialists of his era.
Metcalf began his NFL career with the Cleveland Browns in 1989 and quickly made his mark on special teams. His remarkable quickness, vision, and agility made him a constant threat to break off long returns and change the momentum of games.
Metcalf's peak single-season performance came in 1997, his only season with the San Diego Chargers. He amassed 489 punt return yards and scored three punt return touchdowns, showcasing his ability to make defenders miss and create big plays. Additionally, he contributed 355 kick return yards, further demonstrating his impact on the return game. Metcalf's all-purpose yardage that season totaled 1,415 yards, highlighting his versatility and value to the team.
Throughout his career, Metcalf consistently demonstrated his game-breaking ability on both punt and kick returns. He accumulated an impressive 3,453 punt return yards and scored 10 punt return touchdowns, using his speed and elusiveness to create big plays. As a kick returner, Metcalf was equally effective, amassing 5,813 kick return yards and scoring two kick return touchdowns. His punt return touchdown total ranks third all-time in NFL history, a testament to his game-changing ability.
In addition to his return skills, Metcalf was also a talented running back and wide receiver. He rushed for 2,392 yards and 12 touchdowns while also catching 541 passes for 5,572 yards and 31 touchdowns. Metcalf's versatility and ability to contribute in multiple phases of the game made him a valuable asset to his teams.
Metcalf's consistent excellence and game-changing ability earned him numerous individual accolades. He was selected to three Pro Bowls (1990, 1993, 1994) and named First-Team All-Pro two times (1993, 1997), cementing his status as one of the elite return specialists and all-purpose players of his generation.
Off the field, Metcalf was known for his quiet demeanor, strong work ethic, and commitment to his craft. He was a respected teammate and a key contributor to the success of the teams he played for.
Eric Metcalf's legacy as one of the most dynamic and versatile return specialists in NFL history is secure. His exceptional speed, elusiveness, and ability to create game-changing plays on both punt and kick returns made him a constant threat and a respected opponent. Metcalf's contributions to the Browns franchise and his impact on the return game will always be remembered and celebrated by fans and football enthusiasts. His career serves as a testament to the value of versatility, explosiveness, and the potential to alter the course of a game with electrifying returns and all-purpose abilities.
9. Dante Hall
Team(s):
- Kansas City Chiefs (2000-2006)
- St. Louis Rams (2007)
Accolades:
- Hall of Fame induction: No
- First-Team All-Pro selections: 1
- Pro Bowls: 2
Summary:
Dante Hall, nicknamed "The Human Joystick," was a dynamic and electrifying return specialist who made a significant impact in the NFL during his eight-year career, primarily with the Kansas City Chiefs. Known for his exceptional speed, agility, and game-breaking ability, Hall established himself as one of the most exciting and feared return specialists of his era.
Hall began his NFL career with the Kansas City Chiefs in 2000 and quickly made his mark on special teams. His remarkable quickness, elusiveness, and vision made him a constant threat to break off long returns and change the complexion of games.
Hall's peak single-season performance came in 2003, his fourth year with the Chiefs. He amassed 472 punt return yards and scored two punt return touchdowns, showcasing his ability to make defenders miss and create big plays. Additionally, he contributed 1,478 kick return yards and scored two kick return touchdowns, further demonstrating his impact on the return game. Hall's all-purpose yardage that season totaled 2,446 yards, highlighting his versatility and value to the team.
Throughout his career, Hall consistently demonstrated his game-breaking ability on both punt and kick returns. He accumulated 2,261 punt return yards and scored six punt return touchdowns, using his explosive speed and elusiveness to create big plays. As a kick returner, Hall was equally dangerous, amassing an impressive 10,136 kick return yards and scoring six kick return touchdowns. His ability to change field position and swing momentum in his team's favor made him a valuable asset to the Chiefs' special teams unit.
In addition to his return skills, Hall also contributed as a wide receiver, using his speed and route-running ability to create separation and make plays in the passing game. He finished his career with 162 receptions for 1,747 yards and nine touchdowns.
Hall's consistent excellence and game-changing ability earned him numerous individual accolades. He was selected to two Pro Bowls (2002, 2003) and named First-Team All-Pro once (2003), cementing his status as one of the elite return specialists of his generation.
Off the field, Hall was known for his infectious personality, strong work ethic, and dedication to his craft. He was a fan favorite in Kansas City and a respected teammate throughout his career.
Dante Hall's legacy as one of the most dynamic and electrifying return specialists in NFL history is secure. His exceptional speed, agility, and ability to create game-changing plays on both punt and kick returns made him a constant threat and a respected opponent. Hall's contributions to the Chiefs franchise and his impact on the return game will always be remembered and celebrated by fans and football enthusiasts. His career serves as a testament to the value of explosive playmaking ability, elusiveness, and the potential to alter the course of a game with thrilling returns that brought fans to their feet.
8. Justin Miller
Team(s):
- New York Jets (2005-2008)
- Oakland Raiders (2008-2009)
- San Francisco 49ers (2009)
- Detroit Lions (2012)
Accolades:
- Hall of Fame induction: No
- First-Team All-Pro selections: 1
- Pro Bowls: 1
Summary:
Justin Miller, a dynamic and explosive return specialist, made a significant impact in the NFL during his seven-year career, most notably with the New York Jets. Known for his exceptional speed, vision, and big-play ability, Miller established himself as one of the most dangerous kick returners of his era.
Miller began his NFL career with the New York Jets in 2005 as a second-round draft pick. Despite being primarily a cornerback, Miller quickly made his mark on special teams with his electrifying kick returns. His speed, acceleration, and fearlessness made him a constant threat to break off long returns and change the momentum of games.
Miller's peak single-season performance came in 2006, his second year with the Jets. He amassed an impressive 1,304 kick return yards and scored two kick return touchdowns, showcasing his ability to burst through openings and outrun defenders. His exceptional performance that season earned him recognition as a First-Team All-Pro and a Pro Bowl selection.
Throughout his career, Miller consistently demonstrated his game-breaking ability as a kick returner. He accumulated 3,966 kick return yards and scored five kick return touchdowns, using his speed and vision to create big plays. Miller's kick return touchdowns often came at crucial moments, providing a spark for his team and energizing his teammates and fans.
While primarily focusing on his role as a kick returner, Miller also contributed as a cornerback when called upon. He finished his career with 228 tackles, seven interceptions, and two forced fumbles, showcasing his versatility and willingness to contribute on defense.
After his time with the Jets, Miller had brief stints with the Oakland Raiders, San Francisco 49ers, Arizona Cardinals, and Detroit Lions, continuing to make an impact on special teams wherever he played.
Off the field, Miller was known for his quiet demeanor, strong work ethic, and dedication to his craft. He was a respected teammate and a valuable asset to the teams he played for.
Justin Miller's legacy as one of the most explosive and game-changing return specialists in NFL history is firmly established. His exceptional speed, vision, and ability to create big plays on kick returns made him a constant threat and a respected opponent. Miller's contributions to the Jets franchise and his impact on the return game will always be remembered and celebrated by fans and football enthusiasts. His career serves as a testament to the value of explosive playmaking ability, fearlessness, and the potential to alter the course of a game with electrifying returns that could shift momentum in an instant.
7. Percy Harvin
Team(s):
- Minnesota Vikings (2009-2012)
- Seattle Seahawks (2013-2014)
- New York Jets (2014)
- Buffalo Bills (2015-2016)
Accolades:
- Hall of Fame induction: No
- First-Team All-Pro selections: 0
- Pro Bowls: 1
Summary:
Percy Harvin, a versatile and dynamic playmaker, made a significant impact in the NFL during his eight-year career, most notably with the Minnesota Vikings and Seattle Seahawks. Known for his exceptional speed, agility, and ability to contribute in multiple phases of the game, Harvin established himself as one of the most exciting and multi-faceted players of his era.
Harvin began his NFL career with the Minnesota Vikings in 2009 as a first-round draft pick. From the outset, he showcased his versatility by making an impact as a wide receiver, running back, and return specialist. Harvin's speed, elusiveness, and ability to create mismatches made him a constant threat on offense and special teams.
Harvin's peak single-season performance came in 2009, his first year in the league. He amassed 1,156 kick return yards and scored two kick return touchdowns, demonstrating his impact on the return game. Harvin's all-purpose yardage that season totaled 2,081 yards, highlighting his versatility and value to the team.
Throughout his career, Harvin consistently demonstrated his game-breaking ability as a return specialist. As a kick returner, Harvin was dangerous, amassing 4,127 kick return yards and scoring five kick return touchdowns. His ability to change field position and create instant offense made him a valuable asset to his teams.
In addition to his return skills, Harvin was a dynamic playmaker on offense. He caught 353 passes for 4,026 yards and 22 touchdowns while also rushing for 927 yards and five touchdowns. Harvin's versatility and ability to line up at various positions made him a matchup nightmare for opposing defenses.
Harvin's exceptional performance in his rookie season earned him recognition as a Pro Bowl selection in 2009. He continued to be a key contributor throughout his career, including playing a crucial role in the Seattle Seahawks' Super Bowl XLVIII victory over the Denver Broncos, where he returned the second-half opening kickoff for a touchdown.
Off the field, Harvin faced some challenges and controversies, but his on-field impact and ability to create excitement remained undeniable.
Percy Harvin's legacy as one of the most dynamic and versatile return specialists in NFL history is secure. His exceptional speed, agility, and ability to contribute in multiple phases of the game made him a constant threat and a respected opponent. Harvin's contributions to the Vikings and Seahawks franchises, as well as his impact on the return game and offense, will always be remembered and celebrated by fans and football enthusiasts. His career serves as a testament to the value of versatility, explosive playmaking ability, and the potential to change the course of a game with electrifying returns and game-breaking plays on offense.
6. Cordarrelle Patterson
Team(s):
- Minnesota Vikings (2013-2016)
- Oakland Raiders (2017)
- New England Patriots (2018)
- Chicago Bears (2019-2020)
- Atlanta Falcons (2021-2023)
Accolades:
- Hall of Fame induction: No
- First-Team All-Pro selections: 4
- Pro Bowls: 4
Summary:
Cordarrelle Patterson, a versatile and dynamic playmaker, has made a significant impact in the NFL since entering the league in 2013. Known for his exceptional speed, elusiveness, and ability to contribute in multiple phases of the game, Patterson has established himself as one of the most exciting and multi-faceted players of his generation.
Patterson began his NFL career with the Minnesota Vikings in 2013 as a first-round draft pick. From the outset, he showcased his game-breaking ability as a return specialist, using his speed and vision to create big plays on kickoff returns. Patterson's impact on special teams was immediate, as he quickly became one of the most feared return men in the league.
Patterson's peak single-season performance as a return specialist came in his rookie year, 2013. He amassed 1,393 kick return yards and scored two kick return touchdowns, electrifying fans and solidifying his status as a game-changer on special teams. His all-purpose yardage that season totaled 2,020 yards, highlighting his versatility and value to the team.
Throughout his career, Patterson has consistently demonstrated his prowess as a return specialist. He has accumulated 7,989 kick return yards and scored an impressive nine kick return touchdowns, using his speed, elusiveness, and vision to create big plays. Patterson's ability to flip field position and generate instant offense has made him a valuable asset to every team he has played for.
In addition to his return skills, Patterson has made significant contributions as a wide receiver and running back. He has caught 298 passes for 2,795 yards and 16 touchdowns while also rushing for 2,511 yards and 22 touchdowns. Patterson's versatility and ability to line up at various positions have made him a matchup nightmare for opposing defenses.
Patterson's exceptional performances have earned him numerous individual accolades. He has been selected to four Pro Bowls (2013, 2016, 2019, 2020) and named First-Team All-Pro four times (2013, 2016, 2019, 2020), cementing his status as one of the elite return specialists and versatile playmakers of his era.
Off the field, Patterson is known for his infectious personality, strong work ethic, and leadership skills. He is a respected teammate and a fan favorite, thanks to his exciting play and ability to make game-changing moments.
Cordarrelle Patterson's legacy as one of the most explosive and game-changing return specialists in NFL history is firmly established. His exceptional speed, elusiveness, and ability to contribute in multiple phases of the game have made him a constant threat and a respected opponent. Patterson's impact on the return game, offense, and the teams he has played for will be remembered and celebrated by fans and football enthusiasts. His career serves as a testament to the value of versatility, explosive playmaking ability, and the potential to change the course of a game with electrifying returns and game-breaking plays on offense. As Patterson continues to showcase his skills and leave his mark on the NFL, his place among the all-time great return specialists and versatile playmakers becomes increasingly solidified.
5. Tyreek Hill
Team(s):
- Kansas City Chiefs (2016-2021)
- Miami Dolphins (2022-2023)
Accolades:
- Hall of Fame induction: No
- First-Team All-Pro selections: 5
- Pro Bowls: 8
Summary:
Tyreek Hill, nicknamed "Cheetah," is a dynamic and explosive playmaker who has taken the NFL by storm since entering the league in 2016. Known for his blistering speed, elusiveness, and game-breaking ability, Hill has established himself as one of the most feared and electric players of his generation.
Hill began his NFL career with the Kansas City Chiefs in 2016 as a fifth-round draft pick. Despite his relatively late draft position, Hill quickly made his mark on the league with his exceptional performance as a return specialist and wide receiver. His speed and agility made him an immediate threat on special teams, and his ability to stretch the field and create separation as a receiver added another dimension to the Chiefs' offense.
Hill's peak single-season performance as a return specialist came in his rookie year, 2016. He amassed 592 punt return yards and scored two punt return touchdowns, showcasing his ability to make defenders miss and create big plays. Additionally, he contributed 384 kick return yards and scored one kick return touchdown, further demonstrating his impact on the return game. Hill's all-purpose yardage that season totaled 1,836 yards, highlighting his versatility and value to the team.
Throughout his career, Hill has consistently demonstrated his game-breaking ability as a return specialist. He has accumulated 1,005 punt return yards and scored four punt return touchdowns, using his speed and elusiveness to create big plays.
While Hill's return abilities are remarkable, his impact as a wide receiver has been equally significant. He has caught 717 passes for 10,139 yards and 76 touchdowns, averaging an impressive 14.1 yards per reception. Hill's speed, route-running skills, and ability to create separation have made him a nightmare for opposing defenses and a favorite target for his quarterbacks.
Hill's exceptional performances have earned him numerous individual accolades. He has been selected to eight consecutive Pro Bowls (2016-2023) and named First-Team All-Pro five times (2016, 2018, 2020, 2022, 2023), cementing his status as one of the elite playmakers in the NFL.
Off the field, Hill has faced controversy and legal issues, but his on-field impact and ability to create excitement have remained undeniable.
Tyreek Hill's legacy as one of the most dynamic and electrifying return specialists in NFL history is secure, despite his relatively short time as a return man. His blistering speed, elusiveness, and ability to contribute in multiple phases of the game have made him a constant threat and a respected opponent. Hill's impact on the Chiefs' success during his tenure with the team and his continued excellence with the Miami Dolphins have solidified his place among the most electric and game-breaking players in NFL history. As Hill continues to showcase his skills and leave his mark on the league, his potential to be remembered as one of the all-time great return specialists and playmakers only grows stronger.
4. Travis Williams
Team(s):
- Green Bay Packers (1967-1970)
- Los Angeles Rams (1971)
Accolades:
- Hall of Fame induction: No
- First-Team All-Pro selections: 0
- Pro Bowls: 0
Summary:
Travis Williams, a dynamic and electrifying return specialist, made a significant impact in the NFL during his short but remarkable career in the late 1960s and early 1970s. Known for his exceptional speed, elusiveness, and game-breaking ability, Williams established himself as one of the most feared and exciting return men of his era.
Williams began his NFL career with the Green Bay Packers in 1967 and quickly made his mark on special teams. His blazing speed and ability to make defenders miss in the open field made him a constant threat to take any punt or kickoff return the distance. Williams' impact on the return game was immediate and undeniable.
Williams' peak single-season performance came in 1969, his third year with the Packers. He amassed 189 punt return yards and scored one punt return touchdown, showcasing his ability to create big plays and change the momentum of games. Additionally, he contributed 517 kick return yards and scored one kick return touchdown, further demonstrating his game-breaking ability. Williams' all-purpose yardage that season totaled 1,517 yards, highlighting his versatility and value to the team.
Throughout his career, Williams consistently demonstrated his prowess as a return specialist. He accumulated 213 punt return yards and scored one punt return touchdown, using his speed and elusiveness to create big plays. As a kick returner, Williams was even more impressive, amassing 2,801 kick return yards and scoring six kick return touchdowns. His ability to flip field position and generate instant offense made him a valuable asset to the Packers.
In addition to his return skills, Williams also contributed as a running back, rushing for 1,166 yards and six touchdowns during his career. His versatility and ability to impact the game in multiple ways made him a respected and feared opponent.
Tragically, Williams' career was cut short when a knee injury ended his career prematurely in the 1972 season, limiting him to just five seasons in the NFL. Despite his short career, his impact on the game and his electrifying performances left a lasting impression on fans and teammates alike.
Travis Williams' legacy as one of the most dynamic and versatile return specialists in NFL history is secure. His exceptional speed, elusiveness, and ability to create big plays on both punt and kick returns made him a constant threat and a respected opponent. Williams' contributions to the Packers franchise and his impact on the return game during his short but remarkable career will always be remembered and celebrated by fans and football historians. His career serves as a testament to the value of explosive playmaking ability and the potential to alter the course of a game with electrifying returns, leaving an indelible mark on the sport despite his tragically brief time in the NFL.
3. Gale Sayers
Team(s):
- Chicago Bears (1965-1971)
Accolades:
- Hall of Fame induction: Yes
- First-Team All-Pro selections: 5
- Pro Bowls: 5
Summary:
Gale Sayers, a legendary running back and return specialist, left an indelible mark on the NFL during his short but extraordinary career with the Chicago Bears in the 1960s. Known for his incredible speed, agility, and game-breaking ability, Sayers established himself as one of the most electrifying and dynamic players in league history.
Sayers burst onto the scene as a rookie in 1965, immediately showcasing his talent as a return specialist. His exceptional speed and elusiveness made him a constant threat to take any punt or kickoff return the distance. Sayers' impact on the return game was instant and undeniable, as he quickly became one of the most feared and exciting players in the league.
Sayers' peak single-season performance as a return specialist came in his rookie year, 1965. He amassed 80 punt return yards and scored one punt return touchdown, showcasing his ability to create big plays and change the momentum of games. Additionally, he contributed 603 kick return yards and scored three kick return touchdowns, further demonstrating his game-breaking ability. Sayers' all-purpose yardage that season totaled an impressive 1,689 yards, highlighting his versatility and value to the Bears.
Throughout his career, Sayers consistently demonstrated his prowess as a return specialist. He accumulated 391 punt return yards and scored two punt return touchdowns, using his speed and elusiveness to create big plays. As a kick returner, Sayers was equally impressive, amassing 2,781 kick return yards and scoring six kick return touchdowns. His ability to flip field position and generate instant offense made him a valuable asset to the Bears.
While Sayers' return abilities were remarkable, his impact as a running back was equally significant. He rushed for 4,956 yards and 39 touchdowns, averaging an impressive 5.0 yards per carry. Sayers' speed, vision, and ability to make defenders miss in the open field made him a nightmare for opposing defenses and a favorite among fans.
Sayers' exceptional performances earned him numerous individual accolades. He was selected to five Pro Bowls (1965-1969) and named First-Team All-Pro five times (1965-1969), cementing his status as one of the elite players of his era. In 1977, Sayers was inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame, recognizing his immense contributions to the sport.
Tragically, Sayers' career was cut short due to knee injuries, limiting him to just seven seasons in the NFL. Despite the brevity of his career, his impact on the game and his electrifying performances left a lasting legacy that continues to inspire and captivate football fans.
Gale Sayers' legacy as one of the greatest return specialists in NFL history is forever etched in NFL history. His incredible speed, agility, and ability to create big plays on both punt and kick returns, as well as his remarkable skills as a running back, made him a true icon of the sport. Sayers' contributions to the Bears franchise and his impact on the game during his short but brilliant career will always be remembered and celebrated by fans and football historians. His career serves as a testament to the value of explosive playmaking ability and the potential to leave an indelible mark on the sport, even in a relatively brief time. Gale Sayers' legacy as one of the greatest players in NFL history endures, and his electrifying performances continue to inspire generations of football enthusiasts.
2. Ollie Matson
Team(s):
- Chicago Cardinals (1952-1958)
- Los Angeles Rams (1959-1962)
- Detroit Lions (1963)
- Philadelphia Eagles (1964-1966)
Accolades:
- Hall of Fame induction: Yes
- First-Team All-Pro selections: 5
- Pro Bowls: 6
Summary:
Ollie Matson, a legendary running back and return specialist, left an indelible mark on the NFL during his illustrious 14-year career spanning from the 1950s to the 1960s. Known for his exceptional speed, agility, and versatility, Matson established himself as one of the most dynamic and influential players of his era.
Matson began his NFL career with the Chicago Cardinals in 1952, quickly showcasing his talent as a return specialist and offensive weapon. His blazing speed and elusiveness made him a constant threat to break off long returns and change the complexion of games. Matson's impact on the return game was immediate and undeniable, as he became one of the most feared and respected players in the league.
Matson's peak single-season performance as a return specialist came in his second year, 1954. He amassed 100 punt return yards and scored one punt return touchdown, demonstrating his ability to create big plays and swing momentum in his team's favor. Additionally, he contributed 449 kick return yards and scored one kick return touchdown, further showcasing his game-breaking ability. Matson's all-purpose yardage that season totaled 1,666 yards, highlighting his versatility and value to the Cardinals.
Throughout his career, Matson consistently demonstrated his prowess as a return specialist. He accumulated 595 punt return yards and scored three punt return touchdowns, using his speed and elusiveness to create big plays. As a kick returner, Matson was even more impressive, amassing 3,746 kick return yards and scoring six kick return touchdowns. His ability to flip field position and generate instant offense made him a valuable asset to every team he played for.
While Matson's return abilities were remarkable, his impact as a running back and receiver was equally significant. He rushed for 5,173 yards and 40 touchdowns, averaging an impressive 4.4 yards per carry. Matson also caught 222 passes for 3,285 yards and 23 touchdowns, showcasing his versatility and ability to contribute in multiple facets of the game.
Matson's exceptional performances earned him numerous individual accolades. He was selected to six Pro Bowls (1952, 1954-1958) and named First-Team All-Pro five times (1952, 1954-1957), cementing his status as one of the elite players of his generation. In 1972, Matson was inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame, recognizing his immense contributions to the sport.
Off the field, Matson was known for his humble demeanor and dedication to his craft. He was a respected teammate and a true professional, leaving a lasting impact on the teams he played for and the players he inspired.
Ollie Matson's legacy as one of the most dynamic and versatile return specialists in NFL history is firmly established. His exceptional speed, agility, and ability to create big plays on both punt and kick returns, as well as his remarkable skills as a running back and receiver, made him a true icon of the sport. Matson's contributions to the Cardinals, Rams, Lions, and Eagles franchises, and his impact on the game during his illustrious career, will always be remembered and celebrated by fans and football historians. His career serves as a testament to the value of explosive playmaking ability, versatility, and the potential to leave an indelible mark on the sport through sheer talent and dedication. Ollie Matson's legacy as one of the greatest all-around players in NFL history endures, and his electrifying performances continue to inspire generations of football enthusiasts.
1. Devin Hester
Team(s):
- Chicago Bears (2006-2013)
- Atlanta Falcons (2014-2015)
- Baltimore Ravens (2016)
- Seattle Seahawks (2016)
Accolades:
- Hall of Fame induction: No
- First-Team All-Pro selections: 3
- Pro Bowls: 4
Summary:
Devin Hester, widely regarded as the greatest return specialist in NFL history, left an indelible mark on the game during his illustrious 11-year career. Known for his electrifying speed, unparalleled elusiveness, and game-breaking ability, Hester established himself as a true icon and a feared weapon on special teams.
Hester began his NFL career with the Chicago Bears in 2006 as a second-round draft pick. From the moment he stepped onto the field, it was evident that he possessed a rare talent for returning punts and kickoffs. Hester's ability to make defenders miss, find seams, and accelerate past would-be tacklers made him an instant sensation and a game-changer for the Bears.
Hester's peak single-season performance came in 2007, his second year in the league. He amassed 651 punt return yards and scored an astounding four punt return touchdowns, showcasing his ability to create big plays and swing momentum in his team's favor. Additionally, he contributed 934 kick return yards and scored two kick return touchdowns, further demonstrating his game-breaking ability. Hester's total of six return touchdowns that season remains one of the most impressive single-season achievements in NFL history.
Throughout his career, Hester consistently demonstrated his dominance as a return specialist. He accumulated 3,695 punt return yards and scored an NFL-record 14 punt return touchdowns, striking fear into the hearts of opposing special teams units. As a kick returner, Hester was equally impressive, amassing 7,333 kick return yards and scoring five kick return touchdowns. His combined total of 19 return touchdowns is an NFL record that may stand the test of time.
Hester's impact on the game extended beyond just his return abilities. His mere presence on the field often forced opposing teams to alter their game plans and strategies, as they feared kicking the ball in his direction. Hester's ability to flip field position and generate instant offense made him a valuable asset to the Bears and the other teams he played for throughout his career.
Hester's exceptional performances earned him numerous individual accolades. He was selected to four Pro Bowls (2006, 2007, 2010, 2014) and named First-Team All-Pro three times (2006, 2007, 2010), cementing his status as the preeminent return specialist of his generation.
Off the field, Hester was known for his humble demeanor, infectious smile, and dedication to his craft. He was a beloved teammate and a fan favorite, thanks to his electrifying performances and the excitement he brought to the game.
Devin Hester's legacy as the greatest return specialist in NFL history is secure. His unparalleled ability to create game-changing moments, his dominance on both punt and kick returns, and his impact on the strategies of opposing teams make him a true icon of the sport. Hester's contributions to the Bears and the NFL as a whole will always be remembered and celebrated by fans and football historians. His career serves as a testament to the value of specialized skills, explosive playmaking ability, and the potential to single-handedly alter the course of a game. Hester's enshrinement in the Pro Football Hall of Fame in 2024 stands as a testament to his enduring legacy and the indelible mark he left on the sport, and his electrifying performances will continue to inspire and captivate football enthusiasts for generations to come.
The Enduring Legacy of the 25 Best Return Specialists in NFL History
Throughout the history of professional football, the return specialist position has produced some of the most electrifying and game-changing players to ever grace the gridiron. Legends such as Devin Hester, Deion Sanders, Brian Mitchell, and Billy "White Shoes" Johnson have left indelible marks on the game with their unparalleled speed, elusiveness, and ability to flip field position in an instant. As the NFL has evolved, the role of the return specialist has become increasingly vital to a team's success. From the lightning-fast kick returners who can take any kickoff to the house to the sure-handed punt returners who can make the first defender miss and create game-breaking plays, these special teams stars have the ability to change the momentum of a game in a matter of seconds. Their impact on the game goes beyond just the return yards they accumulate, as their mere presence on the field can force opposing teams to adjust their strategies and game plans. The return specialists we've highlighted in this article represent the cream of the crop, each having made a lasting impact on their teams and the league as a whole. From the electric Devin Hester, who holds the NFL record for most career return touchdowns, to the versatile Deion Sanders, who excelled as both a punt and kick returner while also being a shutdown cornerback, these players have set the standard for what it means to be an elite return specialist in the NFL. As the game continues to evolve, a new generation of return specialists is poised to carry the torch and build upon the legacies of those who came before them. Players like Andre Roberts, Keisean Nixon, Rashid Shaheed, and Derius Davis possess the skills, vision, and fearlessness to one day join the ranks of the all-time greats and shape the future of the position. The return specialist position has a rich history filled with some of the most thrilling and impactful players in NFL history. These legendary returners have not only redefined what it means to play the position but have also left a lasting impact on their teams, their fans, and the game as a whole. As the NFL moves forward, the legacy of these all-time great return specialists will continue to inspire and influence the next generation of players, ensuring that the position remains one of the most exciting and celebrated roles on the football field for years to come. Read next: Revealing the 25 Greatest Wide Receivers in NFL History - Explore the top 25 NFL wide receivers, from Don Hutson to Jerry Rice, shaping the league's history with grace and unforgettable plays.